Back to Blog
Expert Guide

Knife Sharpening Methods Compared: Whetstones, Systems, Machines and Pros

By SharpFinder
· Updated
2 min read

Every sharpening method does the same basic job: it removes steel to form a new edge. They differ in control, speed, how much steel they take and how much skill they need.

The methods at a glance

MethodControlSpeedSkill neededWatch for
WhetstonesHighSlowHighHolding a steady angle takes practice
Guided systemsHighSlowLowSetup time for each knife
Pull-through sharpenersLowFastLowRemove more steel and leave a rougher edge
Electric sharpenersLowFastLowCan take off a lot of steel quickly
Belt grindersHigh in skilled handsFastHighHeat if the blade is not kept cool
Water cooled wheelsHighMediumMediumSlower than dry grinding, but keeps the edge cool

Whetstones

Flat abrasive stones used with water. You hold the knife at an angle and work it across the stone, moving from a coarser grit to a finer one. Stones give the most control and can produce a very fine edge, and they work on almost any knife, including single bevel Japanese knives. The catch is practice. The whetstone grit guide explains which grits do what.

Guided systems

A clamp or rod holds the knife or the stone at a fixed angle, so the angle stays the same on every stroke. They are a good middle ground for people who want consistent results without years of practice.

Pull-through sharpeners

You draw the knife through slots with fixed abrasives. They are quick and simple, but they take off more steel than needed and leave a rougher edge. They are hard on thin, hard Japanese blades and serrated knives. They are fine for an inexpensive knife in a pinch.

Electric sharpeners

Motorized wheels in fixed slots. Faster than pull-through and easy to use, but they can remove a lot of steel quickly and are not suited to every knife.

Belt grinders and water cooled wheels

Many professional sharpeners use powered equipment. In skilled hands a belt grinder is fast and precise, and it handles repairs well. The key is heat control: an edge that gets too hot can lose its hardness. Water cooled wheels keep the edge cool by design. Ask a sharpener how they keep the blade cool.

Which to choose

  • Everyday home sharpening: a combination whetstone or a guided system
  • Quick touch-ups between sharpenings: a honing rod
  • Repairs, Japanese knives, serrated knives and expensive knives: a professional

Hand it to a professional

Find a sharpener in your city on the state directory, or read professional vs DIY sharpening.

Find Professional Knife Sharpeners Near You

Search the directory of 6,600+ knife sharpening professionals across the United States. Find mobile services, drop-off locations, and specialty sharpeners in your area.