About
Costello Ace Hardware is listed on SharpFinder for sharpening in Warren, NJ at 61A Mountain Blvd. Google lists it as a hardware store, a home improvement store, a paint store and a tool store. On Google it holds a 4.5 star rating from 303 reviews. It is the only sharpener SharpFinder lists in Warren. The nearest other listed sharpener is Harbor Freight in Green Brook Township, about 2 miles away. Its posted hours cover all seven days of the week.
Price
Costello Ace Hardware has not posted a price. Across sharpeners on SharpFinder that do, the middle price is $10 per knife, and half charge between $7 and $20. Request a quote for an exact price.
Categories on Google
Hours
Hours from Google, updated Nov 14, 2026.
Recent Google reviews
Reviews from Google. Showing 5 of 303.
She kicked my son out for leaving his scooter in the doorway. She asked him to move it and he did then she told him he was banned permanently from the store I am extremely mad and this manger was constantly rushing him to leave he just wanted to buy Pokemon
This is a great hardware store with very knowledgeable and friendly people. The owner Bill is always around ready yo help and so is everyone else. They saved our Christmas after one string of 5 new ones purchased there failed after trimming the tree and only a day before Christmas Eve. Bill and another gentleman worked with the string of lights to problem solve (they had sold out of their supply of the same lights) they discovered the replaceable plug portion of the string was the problem and gave me a replacement. You won’t get that kind of service at a big box store or any other hardware store I’m familiar with. They are the best!
What a wonderful experience I had. The employees were so nice and helpful, and Madison went above and beyond to tell me. Was breathing fresh air. This wonderful gem of a store. Highly recommend!
Calamari were very hard to eat . Very hard to. The main entry on the other hand was great . I had skirt steak and my wife had stuffed salmon with shrimp and it was delicious
I love this place. I can get what I need and be out in a few minutes with the help of Dawn. She is always helpful and doesn't judge me for being the idiot that I am when it comes to these things.
Questions for Costello Ace Hardware
No questions yet. Ask about blades, turnaround or drop-off and the answer shows here.
Location
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Costello Ace Hardware located?
Costello Ace Hardware is listed at 61A Mountain Blvd, Warren, NJ.
How is Costello Ace Hardware rated?
Costello Ace Hardware has a 4.5 star rating from 303 Google reviews.
What kind of business is Costello Ace Hardware?
Google lists Costello Ace Hardware as a hardware store, a home improvement store, a paint store and a tool store. Call ahead to confirm which blades they take.
Is Costello Ace Hardware open on weekends?
Posted hours: Saturday 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM, Sunday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM. Hours can change, so call before you go.
Does Costello Ace Hardware offer mobile knife sharpening?
Costello Ace Hardware is not listed as a mobile service. Contact them to ask about drop-off, pickup or mail-in options.
What other sharpeners are near Costello Ace Hardware?
The closest listed sharpeners are Harbor Freight in Green Brook Township (about 2 miles), Ricciardi Brothers | Your Local Benjamin Moore Paint Store in Green Brook Township (about 3 miles) and Sharp-Rite Tool & Cutter in Middlesex (about 3 miles).
How do I contact Costello Ace Hardware?
Call (908) 757-9100 or visit their website.
For the owner
Own Costello Ace Hardware? This is what visitors see right now
- 4 other sharpeners are listed on this page, and the quote form offers to send requests to them too. Verified Pro
- No photo at the top of the page. Verified Pro
- The About text uses Google's label for it (hardware store) instead of the owner's own words. Free fix
- No price posted. Free fix
- Claiming is free: edit the page, read quote requests and answer questions.
- Verified Pro ($19.99 a month or $99 a year) removes other sharpeners from this page, adds a photo and puts it first on the city page.
Sharpeners near Warren
Keeping your knives sharp between visits
Sharpening at home
Common tools for keeping knives sharp between professional sharpenings.
- King KW65 1000/6000 combination whetstone
One stone with a medium side for sharpening and a fine side for polishing.
- Shapton Kuromaku #1000 whetstone
A splash-and-go ceramic stone that needs no soaking.
- Work Sharp Precision Adjust knife sharpener
A guided system that holds the angle for you.
- Work Sharp Ken Onion Elite Mk2
An adjustable-angle belt sharpener for knives and tools.
- Work Sharp Kitchen ceramic honing rod
Keeps an edge straight between sharpenings.
As an Amazon Associate, SharpFinder earns from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure